Dalrymple comes across an article by Susan Sontag in the American quarterly Partisan Review. It reads in part:
Neither do I dare deride the turn toward the East (or more generally, to the wisdom of the nonwhite world) on the part of a tiny group of young people — however uninformed and jejune the adherence usually is. (But then nothing could be more ignorant than Fiedler’s insinuation that Oriental modes of thought are ‘feminine’ and ‘passive,’ which is the reason the demasculinised kids are drawn to them.) Why shouldn’t they look for wisdom elsewhere? If America is the culmination of Western white civilisation, as everyone from the Left to the Right declares, then there must be something terribly wrong with Western white civilisation. This is a painful truth; few of us want to go that far. It’s easier, much easier, to accuse the kids, to reproach them for being ‘non-participants in the past’ and ‘drop-outs from history.’ But it isn’t real history Fiedler is referring to with such solicitude. It’s just our history, which he claims is identical with ‘the tradition of the human,’ the tradition of ‘reason’ itself. Of course, it’s hard to assess life on this planet from a genuinely world-historical perspective; the effort induces vertigo and seems like an invitation to suicide. But from a world-historical perspective, that local history that some young people are repudiating (with their fondness for dirty words, their peyote, their macrobiotic rice, their Dadaist art, etc.) looks a good deal less pleasing and less self-evidently worthy of perpetuation. The truth is that Mozart, Pascal, Boolean algebra, Shakespeare, parliamentary government, baroque churches, Newton, the emancipation of women, Kant, Marx, Balanchine ballets, et al., don’t redeem what this particular civilisation has wrought upon the world. The white race is the cancer of human history; it is the white race and it alone — its ideologies and inventions — which eradicates autonomous civilizations wherever it spreads, which has upset the ecological balance of the planet, which now threatens the very existence of life itself. What the Mongol hordes threaten is far less frightening than the damage that western ‘Faustian’ man, with his idealism, his magnificent art, his sense of intellectual adventure, his world-devouring energies for conquest, has already done, and further threatens to do.
Dalrymple comments:
The question with assertions of this nature is whether they can ever correspond to any genuine feeling, or are but the manifestation of a straining after feeling. To me they have the authentic ring of humbug, which is the besetting sin of our age (which is not to say that it has existed or been prevalent in no other).
Hazlitt (‘On cant and hypocrisy’, London Weekly Review, 1828) tells us that
sincerity has to do with the connexion between our words and thoughts, and not between our belief and actions. The last constantly belie the strongest convictions and resolutions in the best of men; it is only the base and dishonest who give themselves credit with their tongue, for sentiments and opinions which in their hearts they disown.
To this, says Dalrymple,
he might have added feeling, for expressed feelings can be as divorced from true feelings as cant can be from true belief. The complexity of the human mind is such that we can easily disguise the divorce from ourselves and deny that it exists, the denial leading us to act as if the false were true.
Dalrymple does not believe that Sontag
thought or felt of herself as a cancerous cell, for such a sincere thought or feeling is really possible only to someone with a mental state akin to Cotard’s syndrome, the rare delusion that one is already (and deservedly) dead or putrefying: and people with Cotard’s syndrome do not write essays, not even for the Partisan Review.
He adds:
The grandiose moral exhibitionism of which the Sontag quotation is so notable an example serves another function in our moral economy: to divert the locus of our moral concern from the pettiness of our daily existences to the largest general problems facing the world.
It renders alien to us, he says, the Blakean thought (Jerusalem, f. 55, ll. 48–53, 60–6):
And many conversèd on these things as they labour’d at the furrow,
Saying: ‘It is better to prevent misery than to release from misery;
It is better to prevent error than to forgive the criminal.
Labour well the Minute Particulars: attend to the Little Ones;
And those who are in misery cannot remain so long,
If we do but our duty: labour well the teeming Earth.…
He who would do good to another must do it in Minute Particulars.
General Good is the plea of the scoundrel, hypocrite, and flatterer;
For Art and Science cannot exist but in minutely organised Particulars,
And not in generalising Demonstrations of the Rational Power:
The Infinite alone resides in Definite and Determinate Identity.
Establishment of Truth depends on destruction of Falsehood continually,
On Circumcision, not on Virginity, O Reasoners of Albion!
Comments
In a real ideological clash of civilizations,Jews feel the immense pressure of the moving contenents of Islam and the West. It looks so inevitable for the weak and emotional Jews to separate themselves from the hated West+Israel, and at the second time join the international rebel masses(not white ones now). Being Jewish myself ,i see and wait for the same result of this unification.
I agree completely….t “white western civilization is the scourge of every living creature on the planet. I have chronic fatigue issues,and the only way I have been able to express this is in writing lyrics.
Normalized Insanity
Verse 1
I’m a transistorized, transgenederized,
transmogrified trans-human
A corporatized, commercialized,
industrial-strength consumer
A goal setting, gym sweating,
debt fretting freak
A social climbing net-worker
that’s always on heat
I got my education, majoring
in indoctrination
Where they taught me to comply,
to never question why
And so I’m chasing an illusion,
of success that’s a delusion
That is sending me insane,
exploding my brain
Refrain 1
The secret is to hide
That you’re really dying inside
And so I always wear a smile
Coz,I’m living in denial
Verse 2
Its all about profits and making a deal
Dressing for success and spinning a spiel
You can be an individual as long as you conform’
To accepted institutionalized social norms
Refrain 2
If you want to be part of the game
You have to disconnect your brain
Now remember you are not a man
You’re not human no,
You are just a brand
Interlude
Verse 3
There’s no greater profanity
Than treating your humanity
As a mere commodity
It’s depraved insanity
A system of enslavement
By machine men without hearts
Of genocidal lunatics
That’s tearing us apart
Refrain 3
Bombarded by a media blitz
Of fear and dread
And you’ve gotta buy this
Now just relax and watch Netflix
For your daily indoctrination fix
Refrain 4
You can’t think anymore
That’s not what you’re programmed for
Your programmed to obey
Every single thing they say
Go to war and grab that oil
Poison the water and the soil
Keep it up until there’s nothing left
Until everything, everything is dead
Make sure everything is dead
That nothing can raise its head
And friend’s and family
Make sure they’re history
White man’s burden
(ode to Jordan Peterson)
Verse 1
White man’s burden
Is a white man’s curse
As white man always puts his duty first
And so he went forth off to sea
To fulfill manifest destiny
With the blessing of the church
To spread God’s word across the earth
The New World he did civilize
Drown in the blood of genocide
Everywhere that white man went
He spared no life as was his bent
And he thanked the lord with cross in hand
For the gift of stolen land
Verse 2
The godless heathen were sent to school
To learn the virtue of Christian rules
And of conformity that stripped them of their identity
Obedient to white man’s authority
Ready to join in society
Another cog in the machine
Make sure you keep your room clean
Proud nations of consumer drones
Who cannot function without their phones
Who live their lives vicariously
Through celebrity airheads on TV
Refrain 1
And doc says take this pill
All you need to do is chill
And study these 12 rules
So you can be a useful tool
And as we fix your faults
You won’t even realize, it’s a cult
Verse 3
And so as our leaders rob us blind
Engaged in endless genocide
We don’t time have time for any of that
We’re all lobsters ready to hatch
In a state of perpetual war
We don’t have enough guns, we need more
And as our children continue to die
Peterson’s got bigger fish to fry
A sick culture he defends
Right up until the very end
A life of normalized insanity
Where life’s a disposable commodity
Refrain 2
And as reality,
Shreds myth fable and fantasy
Only time will tell, only time will tell
Who will survive white man’s hell?